Усе справаздачы
Справаздачы Carcassonne
#14265: "Incorrect scoring for farmers at the end of the game"
#14265: "Incorrect scoring for farmers at the end of the game"
infoneeded: Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі
14265
215
Пра што гэтая справаздача?
Што адбылося? Калі ласка, абярыце з ніжэй прапісаныя
Правілы: правіла гульні не было выканана
Што адбылося? Калі ласка, абярыце з ніжэй прапісаныя
Правілы: правіла гульні не было выканана
Калі ласка, праверце, ці існуе ўжо справаздача на тую ж тэму
Калі гэта так, ПРАГАЛАСУЙЦЕ за гэтую справаздачу. Справаздачы з найбольшай колькасцю галасоў будуць разглядацца У ПЕРШУЮ ЧАРГУ!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Дэталёвае апісанне
-
• Калі ласка, скапіруйце тэкст памылкі, якую вы бачыце на экране (калі яна ёсць).
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
-
• Калі ласка, растлумачце, што вы хацелі зрабіць, што вы зрабілі і што здарылася
Yes. During scoring.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Калі ласка, скапіруйце тэкст на англійскай замест перакладу на ваш мову. Калі ў вас ёсць скрыншот гэтай памылкі (добрая звычка), вы можаце скарыстацца Imgur.com, каб загрузіць яго і ўставіць сюды спасылку.
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
-
• Дзе можна знайсьці гэты тэкст у сістэме перакладу? Калі так, ці быў ён перакладзены больш за 24 гадзін таму?
Yes. During scoring.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Калі ласка, дакладна і коратка апішыце сваю прапанову, каб зрабіць яе найбольш даступнай для разумення.
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Што было намалявана на экране, калі вас заблакавала? (Пусты экран? Частка гульнявога стала? Паведамленне пра памылку?)
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Якая частка правілаў не выкананая ў версіі BGA
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
-
• Ці відаць парушэнне правілаў у паўторы гульні? Калі так, то на якім хаду?
Yes. During scoring.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Якое гульнявое дзеянне вы хацелі зрабіць?
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
-
• Што вы спрабавалі зрабіць, каб выканаць гэтае гульнявое дзеянне?
Yes. During scoring.
-
• Што адбылося, калі вы паспрабавалі зрабіць гэта (паведамленне пра памылку, паведамленне ў радку стану гульні ...)?
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• На якім кроку гульні адбылася праблема (якая была інструкцыя ў той момант у гульні)?
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
-
• Што адбылося, калі вы паспрабавалі здзейсніць гульнявое дзеянне (паведамленне пра памылку, паведамленне ў радку стану гульні ...)?
Yes. During scoring.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Калі ласка, апішыце памылку адлюстравання. Калі ў вас ёсць скрыншот гэтай памылкі (добрая звычка), вы можаце скарыстацца Imgur.com, каб загрузіць яго і ўставіць сюды спасылку.
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Калі ласка, скапіруйце тэкст на англійскай замест перакладу на ваш мову. Калі ў вас ёсць скрыншот гэтай памылкі (добрая звычка), вы можаце скарыстацца Imgur.com, каб загрузіць яго і ўставіць сюды спасылку.
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
-
• Дзе можна знайсьці гэты тэкст у сістэме перакладу? Калі так, ці быў ён перакладзены больш за 24 гадзін таму?
Yes. During scoring.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
-
• Калі ласка, дакладна і коратка апішыце сваю прапанову, каб зрабіць яе найбольш даступнай для разумення.
The red meeple at the bottom of the game board is adjacent to 3 complete cities. But it was only awarded 6 points instead of 9.
• Якім браўзэрам вы карыстаецеся?
Google Chrome v79
Гісторыя справаздачы
19. May 2020 18:15 • FabWolf • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
It happened the same exact bug in the game #88599535. Agains the red meeple (coincidence I presume) scored 3 points intead of 6
19. May 2020 23:40 • MrPieChee • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
In table #88701092 Every single players farming was scored incorrectly. Blue score 22, but should have scored 36. Green scored 28 but should have scored 40.
I can't work out how the scoring is happening, but I think some cities are only being scored for one of the farms they are attached to, instead of all of them.
I can't work out how the scoring is happening, but I think some cities are only being scored for one of the farms they are attached to, instead of all of them.
1. Jun 2020 14:12 • Hasse72 • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
If I would like to check how the scoring has been done in the here mentioned games... How can I bring up the table itself? When I click on the table link, I get only the final results & statistics. Don't find a link to the final table situation...
1. Jun 2020 18:41 • TommyGun777 • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
Farmer only got credit for 3 cities but there were 4
Table: 92299307
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/iXw9RUj
Table: 92299307
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/iXw9RUj
16. Jun 2020 13:39 • Xav • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
Table 95643777 - All Field/Farmer scores incorrect
Black - BGA score: 6; Actual score: 12 => Total Final Score: 166
Green - 12; 15 => 141
Yellow - 25; 39 => 133
Blue - 27; 30 => 122
Red - 4; 15 => 80
Black - BGA score: 6; Actual score: 12 => Total Final Score: 166
Green - 12; 15 => 141
Yellow - 25; 39 => 133
Blue - 27; 30 => 122
Red - 4; 15 => 80
28. Jun 2020 13:46 • toppie123 • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
boardgamearena.com/1/carcassonne?table=97112410
Carcassonne #97112410
In the end of the game, also unfinished cities appear to be counted for 3 points.
(of which both red and yellow have just 1 in the lowermost part of the game board)
Board: imgur.com/CFjNDB0
Scoring table: imgur.com/EvzLu60
Carcassonne #97112410
In the end of the game, also unfinished cities appear to be counted for 3 points.
(of which both red and yellow have just 1 in the lowermost part of the game board)
Board: imgur.com/CFjNDB0
Scoring table: imgur.com/EvzLu60
29. Jun 2020 15:53 • deap82 • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
Same thing in this game: boardgamearena.com/table?table=98504307
The red meeple at the bottom is adjacent to two cities but was only scored 3 points instead of 6.
The red meeple at the bottom is adjacent to two cities but was only scored 3 points instead of 6.
29. Jun 2020 15:55 • deap82 • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
I apologize, disregard my post. One of the cities is not completed...
21. Jul 2020 16:44 • priority_male • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
102618299 The black meeple that scored 6 had 3 completed cities in the field and should have scored 9.
23. Jul 2020 19:35 • NineTonBar • Распрацоўнікі яшчэ не паўтарылі памылку:
Also had a field scoring issue.. field was awarded to Black despite it containing one Red and Black meeples of same size.
postimg.cc/kDQqW5sr
Game URL: boardgamearena.com/7/carcassonne?table=103010050&replayFrom=238#
postimg.cc/kDQqW5sr
Game URL: boardgamearena.com/7/carcassonne?table=103010050&replayFrom=238#
29. Jul 2020 15:04 • apollo1001 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Thank you for the bug reports. I have started looking into this one and would note:
@Melkor85, @FabWolf, @TommyGun777, @priority_male: Your screenshots/replays certainly look like there is a bug.
@Hasse72: Watch the replay to the end.
@MrPieChee, @Xav: Check the game settings - you were playing with first edition scoring rules.
@toppie123: The yellow meeple is scoring for the city above it, not the incomplete one. The red is next to 3 cities so 9 points is correct.
@deap82: Disregarding, as noted.
@Blakeyg: Check the log just above where you have pointed the arrow to - red/black both scored.
I am marking this as a confirmed bug. The bug is 'Not all completed cities around a field are counted'. I will endeavour to reproduce and fix it in due course.
@Melkor85, @FabWolf, @TommyGun777, @priority_male: Your screenshots/replays certainly look like there is a bug.
@Hasse72: Watch the replay to the end.
@MrPieChee, @Xav: Check the game settings - you were playing with first edition scoring rules.
@toppie123: The yellow meeple is scoring for the city above it, not the incomplete one. The red is next to 3 cities so 9 points is correct.
@deap82: Disregarding, as noted.
@Blakeyg: Check the log just above where you have pointed the arrow to - red/black both scored.
I am marking this as a confirmed bug. The bug is 'Not all completed cities around a field are counted'. I will endeavour to reproduce and fix it in due course.
9. Aug 2020 02:20 • boompjon • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #105896668
Move #131
Progression 99%
Both players had 4 farmers on same field at end of game. Black player scored correctly. Red player was not.
Move #131
Progression 99%
Both players had 4 farmers on same field at end of game. Black player scored correctly. Red player was not.
12. Aug 2020 17:08 • bloodiemo • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Same for me in table 06510745
The other player add 3 points for an inexistent farm or with an inexistent farmer and he wins finally for 2 points.
The other player add 3 points for an inexistent farm or with an inexistent farmer and he wins finally for 2 points.
12. Aug 2020 17:32 • bloodiemo • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
are im going to recieve the 20 points i loose?
19. Aug 2020 16:00 • jtil • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I would like to add my exemple :
boardgamearena.com/5/carcassonne?table=107713921#
Yellow scores :
- 6 cities instead of 5
- 4 cities instead of 3
- 3 cities instead of 2
boardgamearena.com/5/carcassonne?table=107713921#
Yellow scores :
- 6 cities instead of 5
- 4 cities instead of 3
- 3 cities instead of 2
19. Aug 2020 17:53 • jtil • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
here again, a bug makes me win more points than expected.
boardgamearena.com/3/carcassonne?table=107725638
6 cities instead of 3
boardgamearena.com/3/carcassonne?table=107725638
6 cities instead of 3
1. Sep 2020 17:36 • David-L • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I just had the same problem on table 109968058 - boardgamearena.com/table?table=109968058. Red Opponent was only credited with 1 city for a farmer and he should have had 2 cities credited. It made no difference to the game result.
Something that might be relevant to finding reason for bug... All other farmers for him and myself were credited correctly, and the only one that did not count correctly was his very last tile and meeple placed in the game.
Something that might be relevant to finding reason for bug... All other farmers for him and myself were credited correctly, and the only one that did not count correctly was his very last tile and meeple placed in the game.
12. Sep 2020 17:42 • priority_male • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #111863341
Move #245
Progression 99%
The north black farmer only counted as 6 points, but it's next to 3 cities and should be 9 points. It would have resulted in a tie instead of a loss.
Move #245
Progression 99%
The north black farmer only counted as 6 points, but it's next to 3 cities and should be 9 points. It would have resulted in a tie instead of a loss.
19. Oct 2020 01:51 • Jeor • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Carcassonne (table #118170725)
Both players had a farmer in same territory with 5 cities. Opponent received 15 points when they shouldn't have, giving them the victory. (upper left hand corner of game board)
Both players had a farmer in same territory with 5 cities. Opponent received 15 points when they shouldn't have, giving them the victory. (upper left hand corner of game board)
9. Nov 2020 03:29 • Asrazix • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Same bug on table #122661175
Red farmer on top left, between 3 castles, is only awarded 6 points instead of 9 at end of game.
Red farmer on top left, between 3 castles, is only awarded 6 points instead of 9 at end of game.
23. Nov 2020 00:12 • krizza-91 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I played this game in training mode yesterday with 1st edition farmer rules and it only scored 3 pts per completed city, no matter how many separate fields were adjacent to that city. This is incorrect; it should be 3 pts per completed city per field. So if there are two farmers with two separate fields adjacent to the same city, that farmer should score 6 pts instead of 3 pts.
23. Nov 2020 23:39 • Kenig2101 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
В конце игры не правильно были посчитаны очки за ткань!!!:(((
29. Dec 2020 19:47 • priority_male • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #135007062
Move #217
Progression 99%
Black farmer in the south should have 4 cities for 12 points, not 9 for 3.
Move #217
Progression 99%
Black farmer in the south should have 4 cities for 12 points, not 9 for 3.
8. Jan 2021 02:25 • ColeGrogan • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table 137403074
Same number of farmers in the field but only one was awarded the 30pts during scoring.
Same number of farmers in the field but only one was awarded the 30pts during scoring.
8. Jan 2021 02:27 • ColeGrogan • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table 137518512
Same number of farmers in the lower field but only one was awarded pts during scoring.
Same number of farmers in the lower field but only one was awarded pts during scoring.
23. Jan 2021 17:42 • Sdani • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
In the Princess and Dragon expansion there is a Tunnel tile. (tunnel goes under city)
In the real rules the field on both side of the city is continuous.
But in the scoring system on the website it doesn't connect.
imgur.com/hIDHLad
Check the big field South-West
Green gets 39 points for 13 cities.
Yellow (me :-( ) nothing
It was a fun game with a mighty opponent, I completely accept her victory. With or without those points!
It's just confusing to follow other rules.
In the real rules the field on both side of the city is continuous.
But in the scoring system on the website it doesn't connect.
imgur.com/hIDHLad
Check the big field South-West
Green gets 39 points for 13 cities.
Yellow (me :-( ) nothing
It was a fun game with a mighty opponent, I completely accept her victory. With or without those points!
It's just confusing to follow other rules.
23. Jan 2021 17:53 • Sdani • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
sorry,
Previous post is a mistake after re-reading the rules in different languages and checking other online platforms.
Previous post is a mistake after re-reading the rules in different languages and checking other online platforms.
16. Feb 2021 22:01 • mansdlayote • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
TataSlo (yellow) wins 27 points with 5 farmers at the end : It's wrong !!! only 4 farmers like me !!!!!
"This pre-supplies 9 city and brings 27 points"
Carcassonne #148603829
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/UGmICMB
"This pre-supplies 9 city and brings 27 points"
Carcassonne #148603829
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/UGmICMB
10. Mar 2021 20:04 • DerSpüler • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Tisch #154475852 during scoring: in the final picture there still are meeples on the board and as far as I can see from the protocol, there was no scoring for the cities (and pig) for red and yellow
30. Mar 2021 13:21 • ziczacclub • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
#159881279
incorrectly calculated points for the fields. please recalculate
incorrectly calculated points for the fields. please recalculate
1. May 2021 23:55 • Chris Hoskins • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I just had a similar issue. I won the game so it didn't make a difference, but a bug is a bug!
Field with 3 completed cities only awarded 6 points
Screenshot here: i.imgur.com/sCtlEdR.png
Table #168960592
Field with 3 completed cities only awarded 6 points
Screenshot here: i.imgur.com/sCtlEdR.png
Table #168960592
18. May 2021 07:45 • EmyBobemy • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
A few games I've played now the farmers and fields have been incorrectly scored - I have the table set to score all fields - it seems to be only scoring majority.
2. Jun 2021 19:57 • sh3r • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
My table also had a similar bug. The farmer was next to two cities and should have scored 6 points but it scored only 3 points. Here is the table #177326381. The green meeple on the bottom left farm.
24. Jun 2021 03:25 • tigun • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #182370134
Red only got 8 points with his farmers+pig in a field with 3 closed cities
Red only got 8 points with his farmers+pig in a field with 3 closed cities
25. Aug 2021 17:43 • knighter555 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
table #196800136, tiny field between 2 complete cities was scored as 3 only
imgur.com/a/BX4wSg4
on the same table, pig didn't add any points to 2 complete cities (should be scored 8 instead of 6)
imgur.com/a/NoAZ8q1
imgur.com/a/BX4wSg4
on the same table, pig didn't add any points to 2 complete cities (should be scored 8 instead of 6)
imgur.com/a/NoAZ8q1
19. Sep 2021 04:14 • Ctout • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
There are 3 tiles (with 3 roads and one city crescent, see image below) showing grass between the road and the city, but during the scoring, it behave like the field does not go through.
There are 3 tiles exactly identical in the game and it is impossible to differentiate them. During scoring, for at least one tile, the field goes trough as it should, and for another one the field does not go through (incorrect). Not sure about the 3rd one.
This was observed during several games,
imgur.com/DvtN7yL
There are 3 tiles exactly identical in the game and it is impossible to differentiate them. During scoring, for at least one tile, the field goes trough as it should, and for another one the field does not go through (incorrect). Not sure about the 3rd one.
This was observed during several games,
imgur.com/DvtN7yL
2. Oct 2021 03:19 • perekati_polya • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #206038469
A red meeple on the left side is located between 4 cities, but it was scored as 9, like if there were only 3 cities.
A red meeple on the left side is located between 4 cities, but it was scored as 9, like if there were only 3 cities.
16. Oct 2021 18:16 • Il paziente 0 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
My big red meeple was adjacent to 2 cities but scored only 3 points instead of six.
25. Oct 2021 15:16 • fivano • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #211621901
Red meeple in top of the map in the field received the wrong count of the score (1 city instead of 3), but green meeple, that connected with me in the same field, received 9 points (for 3 cities)
Red meeple in top of the map in the field received the wrong count of the score (1 city instead of 3), but green meeple, that connected with me in the same field, received 9 points (for 3 cities)
16. Nov 2021 16:24 • Rool87 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Same bug occurred on game boardgamearena.com/table?table=217013067 (green meeple on the top left)
19. Nov 2021 03:18 • mesenius • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Did not count the points for the field with 4 cities in the top right, nor the small field with 1 city in the top middle.
9. Dec 2021 16:11 • TheBigR • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Here is a very clear example:
boardgamearena.com/9/carcassonne?table=219921660
There is a Meeple that should have been tied. It is the only red meople and blue had one actually quite close, this seems like a very simple thing to observe and fix? what's up?
boardgamearena.com/9/carcassonne?table=219921660
There is a Meeple that should have been tied. It is the only red meople and blue had one actually quite close, this seems like a very simple thing to observe and fix? what's up?
13. Dec 2021 21:08 • TheBigR • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Why play a game with a bug, when will this get fixed?
28. Jan 2022 09:21 • Alex_tgiu • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
boardgamearena.com/table?table=236053419 also has incorrect points:
Yellow is lying on 3 cities, but received 0 points.
International rule was on.
Yellow is lying on 3 cities, but received 0 points.
International rule was on.
29. Jan 2022 06:18 • aliciachin7 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table ID: 237126072
3 meeples were sharing the same field. All 3 players should have gotten full points for adjacent completed cities, but all 3 players got zero points.
3 meeples were sharing the same field. All 3 players should have gotten full points for adjacent completed cities, but all 3 players got zero points.
14. Apr 2022 05:41 • LoveCat511 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
In Game boardgamearena.com/6/carcassonne?table=258824702 red player only scored 6 points with his farmers instead of the 18 that were due him.
25. Apr 2022 16:48 • justinjaa • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
During an arena mode game I was awarded 0 points for farmers when set to international rules. This took the win and arena points from me. Table ID Carcassonne n°258510274.
imgur.com/a/L9dgjRo
imgur.com/a/L9dgjRo
18. May 2022 19:39 • Danielavilagomez • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Incorrect scoring in #268425609. In game #268425609 there is an error in the sum of the farms. In the one on the top right of the black color it adds 3 and it should actually be 6.
19. May 2022 07:01 • Krysanumber1 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table # 268558742
Incorrect scoring of mine (black) and red farmers at the end of the end of the game.
Incorrect scoring of mine (black) and red farmers at the end of the end of the game.
22. May 2022 03:58 • Helena2000 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table # 269301404
Incorrect scoring: a field was worth 45 points, red had exactly 5 farmers and 1 pig. Red received somehow 60 points. Pig was worth 4.
imgur.com/a/aKlKd7Y
Incorrect scoring: a field was worth 45 points, red had exactly 5 farmers and 1 pig. Red received somehow 60 points. Pig was worth 4.
imgur.com/a/aKlKd7Y
23. May 2022 19:36 • Helena2000 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #269731958
And here we are again! Red received 44 points instead of 35 (pig was worth 2)
imgur.com/a/wvwfQoG
And here we are again! Red received 44 points instead of 35 (pig was worth 2)
imgur.com/a/wvwfQoG
3. Jun 2022 06:42 • Kittensarepeopletoo • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Carcassonne #272512460
At the end of game scoring I had a meeple in a field surrounded by completed fields (field) image. However I was scored 0 for fields (score). I have inputted files. imgur.com/a/2gP34AS
At the end of game scoring I had a meeple in a field surrounded by completed fields (field) image. However I was scored 0 for fields (score). I have inputted files. imgur.com/a/2gP34AS
4. Jun 2022 08:33 • Kittensarepeopletoo • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
This programme has a bad bug in it. On the field score s put it's meant to be 3 points a field and I had 6 fields so 18 points not 6 and then two fields with one completed city in each. Congratulations on wining but it does make a bit of a mockery of the game.
Replay Carcassonne #272787049
Replay Carcassonne #272787049
27. Jul 2022 19:55 • BTSMatthew • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I had 2 Blue farmers in the same uninterrupted field as the Red player. They got 21 Points and I got zero.
imgur.com/Dp6l1I4
imgur.com/Dp6l1I4
29. Jul 2022 12:22 • helenrbw • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Carcassonne - #287228419. The top right yellow farmer and top left green farmer are both in the same field with one meeple each - only green scored points imgur.com/a/sX5Bn2n
10. Aug 2022 05:15 • BTSMatthew • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Carcassonne - 290360975 - Equal number of farmers (green and blue, 2 each) in same large field. Only green scored.
Seriously this happens in nearly every game I play. Makes me want to stop playing this game on here.
Seriously this happens in nearly every game I play. Makes me want to stop playing this game on here.
10. Aug 2022 11:32 • hotncold2019 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
count of farmers is incorrect for top meeple. it should be 6 but was given 3. It would have moved me from 3rd to 1st.
27. Aug 2022 17:24 • Pitchounetta • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table 295073639 :wrong scoring for yellow farmer's ...
I think the scoring didn't respect the international rules.
I think the scoring didn't respect the international rules.
18. Sep 2022 09:58 • REZONANS72 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I won.But I see some mistake of scoring for my farmer - I got 6 points for field with 3 towns. I Think it about tile with volcano.
game table #300981084
game table #300981084
19. Sep 2022 10:21 • JSM89 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
boardgamearena.com/8/carcassonne?table=301289657
The red meeple got assigned 9 points for the field that has the 2 cathedral cities in it, while this should have been 12 points. With those 3 extra points, red would have won the game. Can this be looked into? Thanks!
The red meeple got assigned 9 points for the field that has the 2 cathedral cities in it, while this should have been 12 points. With those 3 extra points, red would have won the game. Can this be looked into? Thanks!
23. Sep 2022 18:10 • Canardoux • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #302476860. Black Meeple. 1 farmer is counted but I had 3 different farmers. Pig not count.
Just 6 points out of 59 ...
Just 6 points out of 59 ...
8. Oct 2022 21:11 • charlieofRI • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table 305730818, field split by green and red, only green awarded value
3. Nov 2022 20:22 • MrNickP • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
table 314372802
I had already placed a farmer in the field but the game allowed the apponent to place a farmer at a later move. I would have won the game with the points from the field.
I had already placed a farmer in the field but the game allowed the apponent to place a farmer at a later move. I would have won the game with the points from the field.
16. Nov 2022 16:08 • Luminógrafo • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I have also the same problem in table 317284293. I'm the red player and the biggest farm is mine (I have majority of meeples, nor the green player). So, with the correct scoring, I'm the winner, but I've been kicked off the tournament also 😅
9. Dec 2022 13:41 • Ouki • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I had the same problem. Table #324982503.
The farmer in the most left was counted only for three points instead six.
The farmer in the most left was counted only for three points instead six.
3. Feb 2023 14:52 • _SpOOkY_ • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
i do not see any points been counted for the grain, sheets and beer/rum.
I had in in a previous session as well, but was not sure and would have not won at that time. i'm pretty sure I would have won this game with 30 points more than i do have now.
I had in in a previous session as well, but was not sure and would have not won at that time. i'm pretty sure I would have won this game with 30 points more than i do have now.
21. Feb 2023 18:30 • daerelas • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Same problem still exists. In game #349099883, the lower left farmer only scored 6 points but was due 9. I did observe, however, the other farmers on the board all scored correctly but all those were in competition with opposing farmers and had a pig in the same field. Only the single, unopposed farmer with no pig scored incorrectly...in case it helps to determine when/why.
25. Mar 2023 20:58 • FadKrashmor • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Once again a double meeple, red, (with its associated pig) was the only meeple in a field with three cities, but only two were scored (8 points).
1. Apr 2023 13:46 • Rapopo • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
boardgamearena.com/1/carcassonne?table=362536756
In the field there are 5 farmers of the red and blue players, 2 farmers of the black player. Black (me) did not get 48 points for 16 cities, so he was not in first place, but in last. Dislike! The calculation seems to be according to the rules of 1st edition, but international rules are chosen. When choosing rules 1 ed. the calculation is terrible.
In the field there are 5 farmers of the red and blue players, 2 farmers of the black player. Black (me) did not get 48 points for 16 cities, so he was not in first place, but in last. Dislike! The calculation seems to be according to the rules of 1st edition, but international rules are chosen. When choosing rules 1 ed. the calculation is terrible.
10. Jul 2023 17:46 • Mootje1967 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
bij de eindtelling is mijn 2e meeple niet meegeteld en kreeg de tegenstander wel de punten en ik niet/
5. Aug 2023 05:07 • RP19 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Similar bug - table 404052634. Field in upper right corner was scored as 3 points (1 completed adjacent city) but it borders 2. This did not affect the outcome of the game, but is definitely a bug.
imgur.com/a/UfqmD0g
imgur.com/a/UfqmD0g
16. Sep 2023 18:35 • Adult Goth • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Can this please be fixed so I don't have to play against people exploiting it anymore?
17. Oct 2023 19:59 • fafarfadet • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Lien vers la capture d'écran où on voit que mon paysan jaune n'a pas eu ses 9 points pour trois villes dans son champs.
imgur.com/a/wiOapBU
imgur.com/a/wiOapBU
22. Oct 2023 22:57 • dade91 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
The same for me. In table 431087332 my field with two cities (one of them has 3 clothes). They counted 3 points and not 6.
28. Oct 2023 11:35 • MrNickP • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I had 4 farmers in the field and apponent who had 3. The games scored on 3 farmers and awarded win to apponant but it should have been a draw.
28. Oct 2023 20:21 • MrNickP • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I had 4 farmers in the field the same as my opponent but he/she was awarded the points.
8. Nov 2023 18:08 • Tezime • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I lost a game today because of this.
11. Dec 2023 20:29 • bananasplay • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
"boardgamearena.com/1/carcassonne?table=362536756
In the field there are 5 farmers of the red and blue players, 2 farmers of the black player. Black (me) did not get 48 points for 16 cities, so he was not in first place, but in last. Dislike! The calculation seems to be according to the rules of 1st edition, but international rules are chosen. When choosing rules 1 ed. the calculation is terrible."
If red and blue had 5 farmers each, why on earth do you think that black should get points for this farm?
The calculation of 16 cities × 3 points is indeed correct for the international rules, so I don't know what the complaint is here, either. :-/
I replayed this table to see if I could verify or refute this claim, and unfortunately I must refute it.
In the field there are 5 farmers of the red and blue players, 2 farmers of the black player. Black (me) did not get 48 points for 16 cities, so he was not in first place, but in last. Dislike! The calculation seems to be according to the rules of 1st edition, but international rules are chosen. When choosing rules 1 ed. the calculation is terrible."
If red and blue had 5 farmers each, why on earth do you think that black should get points for this farm?
The calculation of 16 cities × 3 points is indeed correct for the international rules, so I don't know what the complaint is here, either. :-/
I replayed this table to see if I could verify or refute this claim, and unfortunately I must refute it.
11. Dec 2023 21:33 • bananasplay • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
"The same for me. In table 431087332 my field with two cities (one of them has 3 clothes). They counted 3 points and not 6."
Viewing the replay appears to bear this one out. Upvoted.
Viewing the replay appears to bear this one out. Upvoted.
16. Jan 2024 22:25 • fmiskolc • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Reporting same issue in game table #457968308. At the end red player's farm at the very bottom of the screen for 3 points isn't scored.
Viewing replay confirms, meeple is definitely on farm and confirmed in sidebar.
Upvoted.
Viewing replay confirms, meeple is definitely on farm and confirmed in sidebar.
Upvoted.
17. Jan 2024 22:24 • Cookiemonster777 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
At my table #463494363, the red meeple in the middle between two cities was awarded only 3 points instead of 6.
25. Jan 2024 07:26 • Drizinho • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table #466561968 - The yellow meeple at the bottom far left received only 6 points instead of 9 for a field with 3 cities.
31. Jan 2024 14:51 • Bieber DJ • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
the statistics at the end show too few points for farmers
31. Jan 2024 15:33 • Bieber DJ • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
the statistics at the end show too few points for farmers
1. Feb 2024 13:54 • Bieber DJ • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
not correct amount of farmer points
1. Feb 2024 13:59 • Wolfimcdolfi • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
the scoring of the farmers was incomplete
2. Feb 2024 14:46 • Wolfimcdolfi • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
the scoring of the farmers was incomplete
27. Feb 2024 14:51 • Peltopeluri • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
I get this today. I had a field with 3 castles, only got 6 points.
7. Mar 2024 13:52 • GhenaW • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Something went wrong in the final scoring
1. May 2024 13:09 • mercapto • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Screenshot, I am green, I share a field with red, 2 farmers each, yet only red gets +24 points.
i.imgur.com/HE7fPzD.jpeg
i.imgur.com/HE7fPzD.jpeg
19. May 2024 18:28 • TB_UA • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
boardgamearena.com/7/carcassonne?table=514526274
Red and blue had the same no of meeples on the same field, 5 each, but red scored only.
Red and blue had the same no of meeples on the same field, 5 each, but red scored only.
19. May 2024 18:33 • TB_UA • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
boardgamearena.com/7/carcassonne?table=514526274
Red and blue had the same no of meeples on the same field, 5 each, but red scored only.
<blockquote class="imgur-embed-pub" lang="en" data-id="a/anwGBT0" data-context="false" ><a href="//imgur.com/a/anwGBT0"></a></blockquote><script async src="//s.imgur.com/min/embed.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
Red and blue had the same no of meeples on the same field, 5 each, but red scored only.
<blockquote class="imgur-embed-pub" lang="en" data-id="a/anwGBT0" data-context="false" ><a href="//imgur.com/a/anwGBT0"></a></blockquote><script async src="//s.imgur.com/min/embed.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
19. May 2024 18:34 • TB_UA • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
boardgamearena.com/7/carcassonne?table=514526274
Red and blue had the same no of meeples on the same field, 5 each, but red scored only.
imgur.com/a/anwGBT0
Red and blue had the same no of meeples on the same field, 5 each, but red scored only.
imgur.com/a/anwGBT0
29. May 2024 01:24 • demdio • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Carcassonne #518414046
One of the fields (the blue pig) has not been scored and the red player was declared the winner, with blue being the true winner.
One of the fields (the blue pig) has not been scored and the red player was declared the winner, with blue being the true winner.
3. Jun 2024 16:33 • GhenaW • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
It is happening often, please try to fix
7. Jun 2024 16:57 • GhenaW • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Field score is incorrect, it Happens a lot
14. Jun 2024 11:23 • GhenaW • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Again!! A city that was mine, huge, was splitted with the other player, unbeliavable… I had 4 meaples on it and the other player 3…. How is it possible, please fix those bugs!!!
20. Jun 2024 14:04 • JSM89 • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Table ID 527562451
Top green farmer was only awarded 3 points while the field had 2 completed castles.
Because of this bug, I lost the game.
Top green farmer was only awarded 3 points while the field had 2 completed castles.
Because of this bug, I lost the game.
22. Jun 2024 18:53 • iparpal • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
No se ha contado debidamente la puntuación de los granjeros
Debía haber ganado la partida por 3 puntos y la he perdido por 3 puntos por una puntuación incorrecta
Debía haber ganado la partida por 3 puntos y la he perdido por 3 puntos por una puntuación incorrecta
25. Jun 2024 17:59 • iparpal • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Un campo del jugador amarillo con un cerdo incluso colocado, en superioridad sobre el jugador verde y rojo, no ha sido correctamente puntuado. Los campos no han valido 4 puntos y la cantidad era insuficiente
25. Jun 2024 20:29 • GhenaW • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
My field was with 4 cities in the end and was scored just for 3
29. Jun 2024 15:39 • nokesian • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
End of game scoring defect.
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/SVQbF0M
Blue and red farmers on the right hand side are both in the same field, bordered by two completed cities. Both should have received 6 points. Blue only received 3 points, but red received 6 points. I believe it is the cloister tile on which the blue farmer is located that caused the problem.
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/SVQbF0M
Blue and red farmers on the right hand side are both in the same field, bordered by two completed cities. Both should have received 6 points. Blue only received 3 points, but red received 6 points. I believe it is the cloister tile on which the blue farmer is located that caused the problem.
22. Sep 2024 18:12 • TB_UA • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Same in top left
boardgamearena.com/table?table=565989827
just cannot get this fields counting - why in top left corder big farmer and a pig i had scored same much as red's big farmer alone ?
boardgamearena.com/table?table=565989827
just cannot get this fields counting - why in top left corder big farmer and a pig i had scored same much as red's big farmer alone ?
10. Nov 2024 19:27 • Pipilud • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Al final de la puntuación, no se tuvo en cuenta los puntos por los campos, cuestión que perjudicó el resultado
12. Nov 2024 00:20 • Pipilud • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
#587753327
Jugada #116
Progreso 99%
Nuevamente no puntuó los campos y perjudicó el resultado del juego
Jugada #116
Progreso 99%
Nuevamente no puntuó los campos y perjudicó el resultado del juego
4. Dec 2024 19:55 • TB_UA • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
also in game
boardgamearena.com/table?table=597597481
JOSANALU - BLACK - scores 48 points with a majority of 4 farmer(s) and their pig (bonus points)
while black had 4+pig and red had 2+1bigmeeple+1pig.
should be 5=5, meaning both black and read would have to score.
boardgamearena.com/table?table=597597481
JOSANALU - BLACK - scores 48 points with a majority of 4 farmer(s) and their pig (bonus points)
while black had 4+pig and red had 2+1bigmeeple+1pig.
should be 5=5, meaning both black and read would have to score.
3. Jan 2025 14:25 • _el_barto_ • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
Have seeen incorrect points counting - in the end of the game (table #609987821) two different players have 1 farmer on the field attaching 8 closed cities but only one of them gains points ( imgur.com/a/Lcz6cJE ). Blue player should gain 24 points for 8 cities too.
10. Feb 2025 22:25 • Gabrielle_c • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
#628392690
I (blue) got 12 points (3 cities including pig) instead of 16 points for the farmer on the right side of the table.
I (blue) got 12 points (3 cities including pig) instead of 16 points for the farmer on the right side of the table.
19. Jun 2025 17:59 • dimarcom • Памылка пацверджана распрацоўшчыкамі:
In the game I just played, a red farmer was not connected to the field, but it still counted and the red got all the field points. I cannot find the game's number but I have a screenshot... how do you see the game number after it's over ?
19. Jun 2025 18:34 • yannsnow • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
You can see the game number in the replay
19. Jun 2025 18:34 • yannsnow • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
You can see the game number in the replay
4. Jul 2025 20:43 • Dav-LM • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
One of my 4 red meeple is near of 1 city but I had not get my 3 points
21. Sep 2025 13:43 • JessieDis • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
game #732097843 miss-scored. joined farm scored to only one player
24. Sep 2025 20:40 • Eztol Odorf • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
Final scoring is WRONG - it indicated that opponent got 9 points for having a meeple with three cities - does not exist.
24. Sep 2025 20:41 • Eztol Odorf • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
Game #734451012 - Final scoring is WRONG - it indicated that opponent got 9 points for having a meeple with three cities - does not exist.
24. Sep 2025 20:52 • Eztol Odorf • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
I was incorrect - scoring was correct.
26. Nov 2025 17:04 • cptn_haddock • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
Green meeple recieved only 3 points despite being adjacent to 2 castles.
Table ID #766308037
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/hodbmlH
Table ID #766308037
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/hodbmlH
1. Dec 2025 02:18 • TheaLuna • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
yep.. this happens a lot.. in my latest game I had 3 small meeples and one big one in the field, the other player had 4 small meeples..My understanding is the large meeple is worth 2 points, no? Th other player got the 24 points.. it would have made a difference to the outcome of the game. :) Thanks.
10. Dec 2025 20:00 • TheaLuna • Распрацоўшчыкі запыталі дадатковую інфармацыю для прайгравання гэтай памылкі:
incomplete street scoring fot 0 whn should have been 7, field scoring incorrect and cost me the game,,, again!
Дадайце да гэтага дакладу
Калі ласка, згадайце ўсё, што вам здаецца значным для ўзнаўлення вашай памылкі або разумення вашай прапановы:
- Іншая Табліца ID / ID ходу
- Ці F5 вырашыла Вашу праблему?
- Ці з'яўлялася праблема некалькі разоў? Кожны раз? Выпадкова?
- Калі ў вас ёсць скрыншот гэтай памылкі (добрая звычка), вы можаце скарыстацца Imgur.com, каб загрузіць яго і ўставіць сюды спасылку.
Змяніць статус справаздачы на:
bug?id=14265
